Court Cases / Nineteenth GMS Court Case

ASOTEKO vs. Bonaire Government 3

ASOTEKO vs. Bonaire Government 3

COURT-CASE FOR STOPPING PATRONAGE IN GRANTING
GOVERNMENT LAND-LEASE PARCELS

There is a virus in the way the Bonaire government grants parcels
of land-lease to citizens. This virus must have affected the government at
least since 1965. This virus is called ‘patronage’. This case aims to root out
this virus in so far as it concerns the granting of land-lease parcels to natural
persons for the purpose of building a personal home thereon. The problem with
respect to the granting of land-lease for commercial purposes is more
complicated and will not be dealt with in this lawsuit. The set-up of the case
is simple. The Court is petitioned to order the government to grant a parcel of
land-lease to the three directors of the Association ‘ASOTEKO’ and a former
director of the Association within three months as of the date the Court
will have ruled in this case. They have been waiting for a parcel from 5 to 11 years.
If the case is successful, this will set a precedent, which will force the
government to handle citizens’ petitions for land-lease parcels
expeditiously, or else the Court will be flooded with similar cases.

Case Files
1. Petition to Court in First Instance Download
2. Replication in First Instance Download
3. Memorandum of Oral Pleading First Instance Download
4. Draft 'Amicable Settlement' Download
5. Exhibit to Memorandum of Oral Pleading Download
6. Change of Petitum and extra exhibit to Oral Pleading Download
7. Judgment in First Instance Download
8. Memorandum of Appeal with all Exhibits Download
9. Policy on Land Bonaire (Grondbeleid 2022 - 2025 Download
10. Evidence (anonymous) of Gross Irregularity in issuance of Land Lease Download
11. Memorandum of Oral Pleading in Appeal case Download
12. Change of Petition in Appeal Case Download
13. Judgment in Appeal Case Download